Customer Support

9am - 6pm EST
Monday - Friday

Toll-Free
+1 (888)-364-7184
International
+1 (786)-655-8855

Damaged, Salvage & Wrecked Subaru Legacy Cars for Sale in Monticello, NY

Showing results 1 - 30 of 40

Auction Car Finder

  • 6966
  • 90
  • 41
  • 13
  • 10
  • 7
  • 7
  • 5
  • 2
  • Popular Makes
  • 961
  • 770
  • 566
  • 561
  • 550
  • 453
  • 379
  • 320
  • 288
  • 230
  • 189
  • 177
  • 175
  • 153
  • 131
  • 111
  • 107
  • 85
  • 79
  • 76
  • 75
  • 63
  • 59
  • 58
  • 42
  • 24
  • Other Makes
  • 101
  • 41
  • 35
  • 21
  • 12
  • 10
  • 9
  • 9
  • 8
  • 7
  • 6
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 86
  • 62
  • 57
  • 45
  • 40
  • 13
  • 11
  • 6
  • 34
  • 6
  • 6
  • 12
  • 20
  • 4
  • 3
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 39
  • 1
  • 11
  • 9
  • 7
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 38
  • 1
  • 1
  • 40
  • 1
  • 35
  • 4
  • 36
  • 4
  • 27
  • 23
  • 22
  • 20
  • 19
  • 17
  • 16
  • 15
  • 15
  • 15
  • 14
  • 13
  • 13
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 11
  • 11
  • 11
  • 10
  • 10
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 24
  • 8
  • 8
  • 38
  • 2
  • 40

  • Sort by

    • Sale Date
    • Sale Date
    • Mileage
    • Mileage
    • Year
    • Year
    • Current Bid
    • Current Bid

  • 2d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2010 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2010 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    220,305 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Doc Type:
    Clear New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - AVENEL NEW JERSEY
    Sale Date:
    04/06/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2016 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2016 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    80,121 miles
    Damage:
    Front & Rear/Left Side
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Pennsylvania
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2011 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2011 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    147,724 miles
    Damage:
    Normal Wear & Tear
    Doc Type:
    Clear New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2006 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2006 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    172,222 miles
    Damage:
    Left & Right
    Doc Type:
    Clear New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $975

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2011 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2011 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    104,464 miles
    Damage:
    Rear/Unknown
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Pennsylvania
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2017 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2017 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    122,707 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $1,750

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2011 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2011 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    223,942 miles
    Damage:
    Normal Wear & Tear
    Doc Type:
    Clear New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $500

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2015 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2015 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    142,367 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side/Front END
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Pennsylvania
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $750

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    162,844 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2017 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2017 SUBARU Legacy 3.6L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    133,126 miles
    Damage:
    Right Front
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    3.6L 6
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    6
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $1,650

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2010 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2010 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    128,871 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    04/07/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $600

    Bid Now

  • 5d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2008 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2008 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    285,930 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front/Left Side
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - MONTICELLO
    Sale Date:
    04/09/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 5d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2018 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2018 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    236,131 miles
    Damage:
    ALL Over/Rear
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - MONTICELLO
    Sale Date:
    04/09/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 5d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2015 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2015 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    205,826 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Idaho
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    04/09/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 5d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2005 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2005 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2005 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2005 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2005 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2005 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    112,335 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Unknown
    Doc Type:
    Clear New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    04/09/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 5d : 18h : 23m : 5s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2017 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2017 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    92,386 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Unknown
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - MONTICELLO
    Sale Date:
    04/09/2026
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2018 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2018 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2018 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    126,346 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Black
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    155,331 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Rear
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    156,532 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    1 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Burgundy
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    136,853 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Doc Type:
    Clear New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Black
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2021 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2021 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    26,543 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2019 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2019 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    62,778 miles
    Damage:
    Left & Right
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2024 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2024 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2024 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2024 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2024 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2024 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    63,130 miles
    Damage:
    Right Front
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Gray
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    150,316 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Brown
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2019 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2019 SUBARU Legacy 3.6L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    142,247 miles
    Damage:
    Left Rear/Left Front
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    3.6L 6
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    6
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2021 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2021 SUBARU Legacy 2.4L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    219,803 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Suspension
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Gray
    Engine type:
    2.4L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2019 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2019 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    72,506 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2011 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2011 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    119,543 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2017 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2017 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    44******
    Mileage:
    75,050 miles
    Damage:
    Rear/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Light Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

Loading

Popular Vehicles

Salvage Subaru Legacy cars for sale by State

We use cookies to analyse & personalise content