Customer Support
9 AM to 6 PM (EST) Mon - Fri
Toll-Free
+1 (888)-364-7184
International
+1 (302)-206-0015

Damaged, Salvage & Wrecked Subaru Legacy Cars for Sale in Monticello, NY

Showing results 1 - 30 of 74

Auction Car Finder

  • 11126
  • 244
  • 175
  • 56
  • 44
  • 40
  • 31
  • 6
  • 6
  • 4
  • Popular Makes
  • 1494
  • 1194
  • 1015
  • 934
  • 843
  • 630
  • 578
  • 566
  • 424
  • 384
  • 323
  • 318
  • 299
  • 227
  • 218
  • 207
  • 151
  • 127
  • 121
  • 103
  • 102
  • 99
  • 85
  • 77
  • 77
  • 37
  • Other Makes
  • 176
  • 69
  • 44
  • 35
  • 27
  • 19
  • 16
  • 16
  • 14
  • 11
  • 9
  • 8
  • 7
  • 6
  • 5
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 135
  • 116
  • 107
  • 74
  • 51
  • 30
  • 22
  • 7
  • 5
  • 3
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 69
  • 5
  • 6
  • 23
  • 1
  • 17
  • 11
  • 8
  • 7
  • 5
  • 5
  • 3
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 70
  • 4
  • 14
  • 14
  • 11
  • 10
  • 8
  • 7
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 65
  • 4
  • 2
  • 73
  • 1
  • 1
  • 69
  • 1
  • 3
  • 70
  • 4
  • 80
  • 66
  • 55
  • 46
  • 37
  • 36
  • 34
  • 31
  • 28
  • 28
  • 25
  • 25
  • 25
  • 25
  • 24
  • 24
  • 24
  • 23
  • 22
  • 20
  • 20
  • 19
  • 19
  • 18
  • 18
  • 18
  • 17
  • 16
  • 16
  • 15
  • 15
  • 15
  • 15
  • 15
  • 14
  • 14
  • 14
  • 14
  • 14
  • 13
  • 13
  • 13
  • 13
  • 13
  • 13
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 12
  • 11
  • 11
  • 11
  • 11
  • 11
  • 11
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 10
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 9
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 8
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 7
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 6
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 4
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 3
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 40
  • 18
  • 16
  • 65
  • 8
  • 1
  • 74

  • Sort by

    • Sale Date
    • Sale Date
    • Mileage
    • Mileage
    • Year
    • Year
    • Current Bid
    • Current Bid

  • 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2019 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2019 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    99,800 miles
    Damage:
    ALL Over/Front END
    Doc Type:
    Clear New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - AVENEL NEW JERSEY
    Sale Date:
    06/23/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Black
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2011 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2011 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2011 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    168,825 miles
    Damage:
    Rear
    Doc Type:
    Clear New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - AVENEL NEW JERSEY
    Sale Date:
    06/23/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2010 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2010 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    230,738 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side
    Doc Type:
    Clear New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - AVENEL NEW JERSEY
    Sale Date:
    06/23/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $25

    Buy it Now $650

    Bid Now

  • 1d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2017 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2017 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    200,699 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Pennsylvania
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    06/24/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 1d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2020 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2020 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2020 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2020 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2020 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2020 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    69,270 miles
    Damage:
    Rear
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    06/24/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Black
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $1,350

    Bid Now

  • 1d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2017 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2017 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2017 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    80,207 miles
    Damage:
    Right Side/Left Rear
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Pennsylvania
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    06/24/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $125

    Bid Now

  • 2d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2000 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2000 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2000 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2000 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2000 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2000 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    145,305 miles
    Damage:
    Mechanical/Right Front
    Doc Type:
    Clear New York
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    06/25/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Beige
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Bid Now

  • 2d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    110,806 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/ALL Over
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    06/25/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $300

    Bid Now

  • 2d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    41******
    Mileage:
    95,902 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Undercarriage
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Idaho
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    06/25/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    Dark Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $25

    Bid Now

  • 3d : 19h : 5m : 36s

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    166,455 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side/Right Side
    Doc Type:
    Salvage New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    06/26/2025
    Bid Status:
    You Haven't bid
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

    Current Bid: $0

    Buy it Now $725

    Bid Now
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2003 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2003 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2003 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2003 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2003 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2003 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    195,548 miles
    Damage:
    Right Rear
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2016 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2016 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2016 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    128,843 miles
    Damage:
    Rear
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    201,712 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2015 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2015 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2015 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    135,610 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Gray
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    83,124 miles
    Damage:
    Front & Rear
    Location:
    NJ - AVENEL NEW JERSEY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Black
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2021 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2021 SUBARU Legacy 2.4L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    70,448 miles
    Damage:
    Left Rear/Left Side
    Doc Type:
    Mv-907a New York
    Location:
    NY - MONTICELLO
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Silver
    Engine type:
    2.4L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2021 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2021 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2021 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    37,865 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Roof
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    29,290 miles
    Damage:
    Front END
    Doc Type:
    Salvage New Jersey
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2010 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2010 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    227,168 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2019 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2019 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2019 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    98,823 miles
    Damage:
    Left Side
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Gray
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2014 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2014 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2014 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2014 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2014 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2014 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    65,669 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    156,021 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - MONTICELLO
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Navy
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    91,440 miles
    Damage:
    Left Front
    Location:
    NJ - PORT MURRAY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Dark Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2010 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2010 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2010 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    227,292 miles
    Damage:
    Normal Wear & Tear
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2012 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2012 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2012 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    223,002 miles
    Damage:
    Right Side/ALL Over
    Doc Type:
    Clear New York
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2008 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2008 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2008 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    234,620 miles
    Damage:
    Left & Right
    Doc Type:
    Salvage Michigan
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    White
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2025 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2025 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2025 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2025 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2025 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2025 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    20,939 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/Right Side
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Black
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2013 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2013 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2013 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    144,114 miles
    Damage:
    Rear/Front END
    Location:
    PA - SCRANTON
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Dark Blue
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2006 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2006 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2006 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    243,386 miles
    Damage:
    Front END/ALL Over
    Location:
    NY - NEWBURGH
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    RED
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline
  • Future Sale

    Swipe to right for more images

    2001 SUBARU - Image 0.
    2001 SUBARU - Image 1.
    2001 SUBARU - Image 2.
    2001 SUBARU - Image 3.
    2001 SUBARU - Image 4.
    2001 SUBARU Legacy 2.5L
    Item #:
    42******
    Mileage:
    250,785 miles
    Damage:
    Normal Wear & Tear
    Location:
    NY - ALBANY
    Sale Date:
    Future Sale
    Color:
    Green
    Engine type:
    2.5L 4
    Drive:
    AWD
    Cylinder:
    4
    Fuel:
    Gasoline

Loading

Popular Vehicles

Salvage Subaru Legacy cars for sale by State

We use cookies to analyse & personalise content